The First Personal World Championship Endgame Composition
Het eerste wereldkampioenschap
eindspelcompositie
Premier Championat du Monde de Problemisme, genre fins de partie
General judgement / Eindoordeel van de jury / Jugement general
|
Place |
Auteurs |
Pays |
1° Note |
2° Note |
3° Note
|
Total |
Place |
|
1 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
136,50 |
134 |
132 |
402,50 |
1 |
|
2 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
152 |
113,50 |
101 |
366,50 |
2 |
|
3 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
134,50 |
108 |
107,50 |
350 |
3 |
|
4 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
133,50 |
71 |
51 |
255,50 |
4 |
|
5 |
S.Rezel |
France |
95,50 |
83 |
60 |
238,50 |
5 |
|
6 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
125,50 |
76,50 |
35,50 |
237,50 |
6 |
|
7 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
112,50 |
57 |
56,50 |
226 |
7 |
|
8 |
A.Kaciuska |
Lituanie |
96 |
65,50 |
33,50 |
195 |
8 |
|
9 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
97,50 |
93 |
|
190,50 |
9 |
|
10 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Biélorussie |
89,50 |
68,50 |
31 |
189 |
10 |
|
11 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
62,50 |
60,50 |
39 |
162 |
11 |
|
12 |
V.Shulga |
Biélorussie |
66,50 |
63 |
|
129,50 |
12 |
|
13 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
69 |
17,50 |
10 |
96,50 |
13 |
|
14 |
V.Bieliauskas |
Lituanie |
94,50 |
|
|
94,50 |
14 |
|
15 |
L.Witoshkin |
Biélorussie |
58 |
32,50 |
|
90,50 |
15 |
|
16 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
87 |
|
|
87 |
16 |
|
17 |
W.Grebenko |
Biélorussie |
84 |
|
|
84 |
17 |
|
18 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
83,50 |
|
|
83,50 |
18 |
|
19 |
V.Muliar |
Ukraine |
42 |
21,50 |
|
63,50 |
19 |
|
20 |
F.Laurent |
France |
11,50 |
|
|
11,50 |
20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
COMPOSITEURS |
NON |
CLASSES |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
J.L.Besson |
France |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A.Butkevicius |
Lituanie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
R.Outters |
France |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
J.Siozinys |
Lituanie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A.Vermeulen |
France |
|
|
|
|
|
|
CATEGORIE A |
|||||||
|
N° |
Auteurs |
Pays |
Gerrit. L de Bruijn |
Rimas Mackevicius |
Petr Shkludov |
Total |
Place |
|
11 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
61 |
75 |
30 |
113,50 |
1 |
|
5 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
71 |
57 |
30 |
107,50 |
2 |
|
38 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
55 |
62 |
38 |
105 |
3 |
|
9 |
V.Bieliauskas |
Lituanie |
19 |
55 |
60 |
94,50 |
4 |
|
22 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
60 |
49 |
28 |
93 |
5 |
|
10 |
S.Rezel |
France |
57 |
42 |
25 |
83 |
6 |
|
17 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belarus |
35 |
27 |
40 |
68,50 |
7/8 |
|
26 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
42 |
25 |
35 |
68,50 |
7/8 |
|
27 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
39 |
17 |
28 |
56 |
9 |
|
14 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
22 |
30 |
25 |
51 |
10 |
|
29 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
40 |
9 |
25 |
49,50 |
11 |
|
6 |
A.Kaciuska |
Lituanie |
31 |
12 |
12 |
33,50 |
12 |
|
19 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
25 |
15 |
10 |
32,50 |
13 |
|
32 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belarus |
34 |
11 |
6 |
31 |
14 |
|
21 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
14 |
14,50 |
15 |
29 |
15 |
|
31 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
14 |
10 |
5 |
19,50 |
16 |
|
30 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
14 |
7 |
7 |
17,50 |
17 |
|
7 |
F.Laurent |
France |
8 |
5 |
5 |
11,50 |
18 |
|
1 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
2 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
3 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
4 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
8 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
12 |
AVermeulen |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
13 |
A.Butkevicius |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
15 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
16 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
18 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
20 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
23 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
24 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
25 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
28 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
33 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
34 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
35 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
36 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
37 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
A1 |
A2 |
A3 |
A4 |
A5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A6 |
A7 |
A8 |
A9 |
A10 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A11 |
A12 |
A13 |
A14 |
A15 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A16 |
A17 |
A18 |
A19 |
A20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A21 |
A22 |
A23 |
A24 |
A25 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A26 |
A27 |
A28 |
A29 |
A30 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A31 |
A32 |
A33 |
A34 |
A35 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A36 |
A37 |
A38 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Author solutions, but see also
PWCE. List of Eliminations. LISTE DEFINITIVE
Explication for the participants of the PWCE
A1.
VP 7 (28-32 A
B) 2 (23 C D) 16 (29 E) 31, 24 (41) 19. If (47) 24, 24+ If (46) 5+
A (24) 2 (27-32 F G) 30 (38) 48 (33 H) 10 (42 I) 31 (39) 27 (44) 5 (49) 5-32+
B (33) 2 (23 J) 7 (28) 11 (27-32) 10 (37/38) 5+
C (24) 30 (38 K) 48 (32) 36-31 etc.+
D (37) 24
(31, 41) 19 etc.+
E (28) 10 (33) 4 etc.+
F (28-32) 30+
G (29) 7 (29-33 L) 11 etc.+
H (32) 36-31+
I (39, 42) 48 (47) 4(38...) 42, 15+
J (24) 30 etc.+
K (37) 24 etc+
L
(28-32) 34 (37) 48 (31, 41) 37, 10 etc.+
Second solution
A2.
18, 3 (19) 25 (23) 14 (28 A) 32 (39) 49+
A (29) 20+
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
A3.
VP 2 (44, 50) 383 (45) 29 (40 A B) 34 (49 C) 30, 40, 19+
A (50) 19+
B (30) 35 (50) 24+
C (45) 11 (50) 6 (45) 50+
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
A4.
VP 17 (34) 8 (40) 3 (45) 7 (30) 3-12 (35 A) 2 (40) 35 (50) 49, 16+
A (11) 6 (50)
7-1 (34) 40 (28) 44, 12 (44) 17, 17+
Anticipation / ressemblance
H.J.van Alphen (Livre J.Bastiaannet Eindspel 1991)
A5.
VP 20, 3 (29-33) 48 Z1 (20 A) 43 Z2 (24 a) 1 (30 b, 9, 38) 29 Z3, Z4 (43) 38, 14 (33) 37 (39) 32 (44) 28
(49 B) 44, 34+
B (50) 6+
A (32) 2 (39 c) 25 Z5 (9, 37 C) 24 (20) 25 (41 D) 40, 39, 36+
D (40, 41) 14 (47) 15+
C (38) 40, 20+
c (20) 16 (33-38) 25 Z6 (24) 14 (37) 41 (42) 37, 49+
Z6= 21 (10) 16 (40 y, 43, 49)=
y (24) 40, 37, 46+
Z1= 43 (9) 1 (32, 38)=
a (9) 1 (32, 38) 15+
Z2= 1 (32 y1) 12 z (33-38) 21 (10) 16 (40 y, 43, 49)=
y (24) 40, 37, 46+
z= 23 (33-38) 41 (10, 25 y2) 41 (30, 40, 43)=
y1 (38) 29 (33, 10, 39) 34 (42) 22 (48) 22-39+
y2 (10, 24) 32, 43 (31) 49+
b (29) 34 (40) 12 (44) 40, 26+
Z3= 17 (33) 50 (40, 42 y3)=
y3 (43) 34-29+
Z4= 18 (32) 21 (37) 43 (40 y4, 41)=
y4 (41) 18-34 (46) 32, 34+
Z5= 34 (37) 24 (40 y5) 19, 41 (33) 32 (10 y6, 38)=
y5 (20, 10, 42) 22 (48) 22-39+
y6 (39) 49 (20) 45-40 (24) 34, 40+
A6.
VP 5 (28 A) 2 (41 a) 23, 46+
A (38) 43/49 (41) Z 2 (46) 32+
Z= 32 (47 y)=
y (46) 2+
a (33) 37/46 (39) 28 (43) 6/50+
A7.
White plays and makes a draw!
20-14 (9x20) 29-24 (20x29 A) 1712 (30-34) 12x1=
A (19) 12 (45) 1=
A8.
Z 13, 42 (41 A) 37, 4 (23 B C) 15 (37 D) 10+
A (23) 3 (41 E) 37, 20 (28 F) 42+
B (37) 10+
C (24) 10 (38) 15+
D (28) 42+
E (28) 21+
F (37) 14+
Z= 42 (13) 8
(41) 37 (32)=
Anticipation / ressemblance
Position 19, 36/9, 48 is mentioned in register 10, paгt
20, 2x2-VЕRZAМЕLING
(Arie van der Stoep, 1993), however without solution, author nаmе
and primary source. Besides in paгt
10, 2x2-VЕRZАМЕLING
саn
bе
found the position 23, 26/9, 48 (black
оn
move) as diagram 43В
[N.N., fгоm
list G.L. Goгtmans
(1894,1956)].
A9.
VP 38 (30 A) 2 Z (7 B) 21 (43 C) 49+
A (43) 1 Z1 (7 D) 25, 48+
B (43) 49, 35+
C (16) 27+
D (30) 1-6, 49+
Z= 1 (7 Y) 31, 48 (49)=
Z1= 2 (7 Y1) 2 (30)=
Y (43) 1-6, 49+
Y1 (30) 49, 35+
A10.
VP 4 (32 A) 15 Z Z1 (40) 16 (44) 11 (49) 3 (43/27) 21, 2, 11+
A (293) 3 (40) 1 (45) 23, 13, 50+
Z= 1 (33) 45 (338)
31 (43) 40 (38) 48 (49) 2, 48-30 (24) 30 (42)=
Z1= 3 (39) 1
Z2 (34) 40 (43) 13 (37, Y, Y1, Y2) 49 (48)=
Z2= 15 (37) 31 (43) 2 (49) 22 (40 Y3) =
Y (48) 31, 40-12, 38+
Y1 (49) 3-8, 2, 37+
Y2 (38) 49 (48) 32 (42 y) 31, 32-21, 21+
y (39) 30, 32-14, 14+
Y3 (38/32) 21, 22-11, 11+
A11.
1 (40 A B) 45 (31 a) 27 Z1 Z2, 1 (21) 6 (27 C) 39/50 (32) 33 (37) 47+
A (39) 11, 48 (40) 39 (45 D) 6 (31 E) 27, 50+
B (21) 6, 44 (31 F) 27, 8/3 (40) 17 (45) 50+
C (16) 39/50 (27) 28+
D (31) 27, 17/6 (45) 50+
E (50) 32-28+
F (18) 27 (23) 6 (31 G) 36 (40) 31 (45) 27 (50) 272+
G (29) 21, 24/15 (40) 33 (45) 50+
Z1= 1 (21 z1 z2) 37 (39) 12 (44 Z3) 21(50)=
Z2= 11, 1 (37 Z4 Z5 Z6) 41 (39 Z7)=
Z3 (43) 21+
Z4 (36) 28, 23+
Z5 (38) 43 (37) 23 (42) 38+
Z6 (39) 27, 1 (43/44) 48/50+
Z7 (38) 34 (42) 37+
a (39) 1 (43) 11 (48)+
z1 (37) 41 (21) 26 (39) 40 (43) 49+
z2 (36) 11, 47+
A12.
12, 5 (29) 8 (36) 3 (34) 28 (31) 33 (37 A) 26 (361) 30 (47) 15 (36) 41, 30-24+
A (40) 12 (45) 50 (37) 29
(41) 47+
Not
two thematic variants
A13.
VP 5 (24 A) 23 (32 B C D) 38 (31) 42 (36) 33 (21) 33-28 (27) 1 (31) 7 (30) 45 (35 E) 34 (41) 37 (23) 36 (40) 22 (45) 50+
A (23) 21 (27
F) 42+
B (29) 34 (37) 23 (631) 41 (37) 21 (27) 42 (32) 37 (41) 47+
C (30) 42 (35 G) 45 (21) 23 (32) 38 (31) 832 (36) 228 (26) 45 (41) 37 (23) 18+
D (37) 41 (29 H) 37 (33 J) 43 (21) 42 (32) 15 (37) 438 (27) 10 (32) 27 (42) 21 (17) 37 (31) 27+
E (41) 37 (23) 36 (34) 22 (40) 28 (45) 50+
F (17) 27 (21) 22 (26) 42 (31) 17 (36) 37+
G (21) 12 (37) 22 (27) 31 (37) 26 (35) 48 (40) 39 (45) 50+
H (631) 23 (37)
41 (29) 28 (21) 43 (26) 39 (33) 17 (44) 50 (32) 33 (37) 28 (42) 37 (31) 27+
J (631) 37x26 (32) 43 (33) 37 (41) 47 (21) 42 (27) 37+
Second
solution
A14.
5 (35 A B C) 18, 7+
A (24) 28 (34) 44 (30) 17 (35) 12 (35-40) 35 (39) 49 (11) 8 (16) 3+
B (11) 18, 16+
C (34) 18+
A15.
34 (17) 48-43 (42 A) 30, 39, 47 (22) 42 (28) 38+
A (30) 32 (39)
27+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Anticipation bу
L. Springer with 17, 25, 38/34, 48, 49 – Dе
Vriendendamkring, Januaryl February 1980.
A16.
12, 4 (32 A) 3 (37 B) 14 (42) 37, 36 (30) 22 (34/35) 44+
A (33) 3 (39 B1) 22 (43) 11, 49+
B/B1 (38) 15 (43) 150, 48+
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
A17.
43 (14 A) 42-38, 38 (19) 33 (24) 38 (30) 32 (35) 27 (35-40) 29, 34 (28) 29+
A (33-39) 40, 29 (14/15) 24+
A18.
VP 4 (21 A B C) 6 (29) 23, 16 (39 E) 49+
A (40) 11 (45) 50+
B (28) 45 (32)
7 (37 D) 6-1 (41/42) 11, 46/47+
C (29) 1 (21) 23... Look at VP.
D (38) 6-1 (43) 11... Look at B.
E (40) 11 (45)
50+
Other
reason.
Solution incompréhensible
L’auteur a commis des erreurs lors de la rédaction de la solution
A19.
VP 1 (44 A) 39 (34) 30, 34 (38) 48+
A (45) 6 (40) 33 (34 B) 38, 49 (28 C) 35 (32) 24 (37) 47+
B (44) 39 (50) 24, 6+
C (29) 35 (33) 30 (38) 48+
A20.
2 Z (12) 4 (23 A) 15 (39 B C) 30 (44 D) 39+
A (33-38) 27, 16+
B (29) 2-24+
C (32-38) 16+
D (29) 8 or 3 (44) 39+
Z= 4 (23) 2 (33-38 Z1)=
Z1 (12) 15 (29 E F) 2-24+
E (39) 30+
F (32-38) 16+
Not
two thematic variants
A21.
2, 11 (37 A B) 20, 14, 4+
A (36) 20, 24, 24+
B (10) 24 Z (36) 4, 4-15+
Z= 5 (33) 32 (37) 14, 15-10 (41) 46 (39) 28 (43)=
A22.
VP 2 (35) 34 (27 A B C) 34-30, 30 (14 D E) 25 (32 F) 27. If (21) 32+ If (43) 49+
A (26) 32 (31 G H) 27, 11 (27) 22. If (31/32, 37) 47+ If (23, 28) 27 (33) 29, 18+
B (14) 32 (23) 24 (26) 33 (19) 27+
C (15) 32 (23) 24 (26) 42+
D (15) 33 (20) 25 (24) 9 (29 I) 31, 48+
E (31) 19 (15) 33 (20) 29+
F (19) 9 etc+
G (15) 11 (20) 27 (24) 44 (23) 6 (30, 31, 40) 31 (45) 27+
H (22) 24 (27, 17) 33 (21) 30 (4)+
I (22) 13 (30, 32) 24. If (27) 19+ If (28, 37) 47+ If (37) 28, 31+
A23.
20, 14, 34, 33+
Not
two thematic variants
A24.
VP 38, 15 (29) 7 Z (31) 2 X (36 A) 10 (41) 19 (47) 4, 23+
A (37) 32, 10 (32) 4 (34) 31 (40) 11 (45) 50 (38) 48+
Z= 10 (34) 5 (40) 28 (31) etc.=
X= 10 (33, 37)=
Anticipation/resemblance
Etude G.Cremer Anthologie 100-3-43
Livre A.Gimbutas Anthologie des erreurs Page 37
A25.
5 (45) 32 (50 A) 43, 25 (40) 39 (45) 50+
A (40) 49 (50)
35, 2+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Strongly related endgame compositlon: 28, 33, 35,45/7, 10,24, 50 – J.
Кlотр,
Concours ‚KNDB 1964’, Het Damspel 3-1965 + Antol. VI-105
A26.
7 Z1 (36) 2 (10 A B) 5 (29) 15-10 Z2 Z3 (34 C D) 4 (40) 28 (45) 22-18 (50) 6 (44 E) 50 (41) 28+
E (41) 28, 47+
C (33) 4 (39) 37 (43) 31, 49 or C2 (44) 31, 50+
D (41) 4 (47) 41 (13) 34+
A (19) 18 (23 F) 20 (41) 14 (47) 14-10 Z4, 24, 24+
B and F (30, 10, 41) 19 (47) 41+
Z1= 26, 7 (30 Y1) 1 (22) 6 (27) 39 (32 Y2) 25 (19) 20 (37) 47 (24, 10, 41)=
Y2 (35) 25 (19) 10, 36 (40) 22 (45) 50 (23) 21 (29) 6 (34) 50 (40) 6 (50) 21-17, 35+
Z2= 37 (34 Y3) 15-10 (40) 4 (45) 22-18 (50)=
Y3 (33) 15-10 (39) 4 (44) 31, 50+
Z3= 28 (33 Y4 41)=
Y4 (34) 10 (39, 41) 33 (47) 15 (41) 5+
Z4= 13 (36) 4 (47)=
A27.
42 (36) 19 (41 A) 37 (32) 38, 33 (20) 29+
A (27-31) 22 (37) 31 (18) 14 (23) 9 (28) 3 (33) 25 (38) 41 (42 B) 37, 14+
B (31) 48 (36) 37+
A28.
4 (40 a b) 4-22 (44 A c d) 11 (41 B) 37 (49) 16 (5 C) 32+
A (45) 38 (26) 6 Z (31) 28-22 (36) 32, 50+
B (49) 16 (10 D) 5 (42) 37, 41 (36) 37+
C (46) 32+
D (5) 41+
Z= 17 (31) 28-22 (36) 32, 33 (41) 37 (50)=
a (42) 38, 16 (40) 11 (45) 50+
b (26) 31 (40) 48 (45) 23 (50) 39, 37, 37+
c (42) 38, 39 (45) C1 C2
C1 39-33 (27) 31 (50) 37, 37+
C2 28 (27) 37 (31) 26 (50) 37, 37+
d (26) 31 (44) 42 (50 e) 23 (45 f g) 19 (34) 43-38 (12) 47 (21 h) 33 (17) 29 (12) 24 (8) 36 (2) 18 (8) 22 (2) 17 (16 j) 14 (38) 19 (15 k) 9 (31) 4 (37) 26 (15-42)
19-13/4-31+
e (49) 48, 37, 37+ or 43-38, 37, 37+
f (22) 19 (22-31) 47 (48) 43-38 (42) 32 (48) 14 (43) 28 (39) 23 (34) 19 (30) 24 (35) 10 (31) 5 (37) 19-14, 41+
g (17) 19 (21) 39 (17) 34 (12) 30 (8) 42-24 (17) 14+
j (31) 26 (11) 42+
h (31) 13 (37) 47-41+
k (31) 26+ or 10 (37) 41, 5+
The position
26, K50 / 23, 43, 46, K42 is win for white.
Second solution
A29.
1 (35 A) 21, 4 (40 B C) 15 (45) 6, 27-22+
A (21) 25, 4 (37) 14 (42) 19 (48)+
B (22) 18 (40) 15 (45) 33, 6 (45) 1+
C (21) 16 (40) 22 (45) 50 (29) 16-11 (33) 17, 6, 17+
A30.
15 Z1 (28 A) 10 (33) 4 (32-38) 44, 39, 15, 50+
A (29, 38) 29, 24, 24+
Z1= 14 (29 z1 38)=
z1 (38, 29) 28, 22+
A31.
27, 21 (27 A) 5, 13+
A (17) 5, 39 (21) 43 (26) 48+
A32.
10 (14) 19 (23) 28-22 (28) 22 (17 A) 28 (21) 22+
A (14) 33 (19/20) 29 (25) 24+
A33.
VP 1 (913 A) 11, 15 (23 B) 4 (19) 13 (28) 2 (32) 24 (37) 47+
A (8-13) 11, 1x29x3+
B (18) 4 (13 C) 10 (24 D) 19 (29) 2 (34 E) 7 (40) 45+
C (193) 22 (29) 39 (13) 11 (34) 7/2+
D (183) 15 Z1 (28 G) 4+
E (22) 7 (33) 16 (28 F) 43+
F (39) 11+
G (18) 33+
Z1= 4 (18) 22 (29) 11 Z2 (34) 2 (23) 7 (29) 18 (33) 40 (38)=
Z2= 28 (34) 14
(39)=
Anticipation / ressemblance
Strongly related endgame (com)positions: 1) 8, 18, 19/10 and 8, 13, 19/15
I.Presburg, Het Damspel 1934 + Antol. I-8
A34.
VP 1 (43 A) 9, 48+
A (19) 24 (43) 2 (48/49) 34/40+
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
A35.
VP 1 (32 A) 1-6 Z (37 B) 12 (8 a) 3 (41 or 42 C) 9, 18+
A (9) 1-6 (32) 28 (38) 33, 34+
B (7) 28 (38) 33+
C (9) 20 (41) 47 (46) 28+
a (7) 1 (41) 28 or 33 (47) 33+
Z= 18-12 (9) 1-6 (8) 14 (37 Z1)=
Z1 (38) 33+
Draw
A36.
30 (25) 24 (20) 15 (30) 10 (34) 4 Z (42 A B) 37 (39) 27 (44) 37-32 (50) 28, 27+
A (39) 36-31, 22 (31) 44 (37) 28+
B (40) 22+
Z= 31, 5 (31)
42 (39)=
Anticipation / ressemblance
Strongly related endgame composition: 9, 10, 37/25, 35, 36, 48
H.J. van Alphen, Dе
Gelderse Dаmmег
1/2-1953
A37.
6 (20 A a) 1 z y (7) 33 Z x (25) 21 (13-18 B) 29 w v (13) 17 Z1, 26 (30) 42 (19 C D) 48 Z2 Z3 (35)
34 (22 E) 39 (27 F) 23, 31/36 (40) 22 (45) 50+
A (13-18) 1 (14) 21 (14-20) 33 (24 G) 29, 17, 16+
B (14) 29 (11 H) 20, 24+
C (22) 31 (18) 23 Z4, 25+
D (35) 23, 2/8 (40) 11 (45) 50+
E (19-23) 45+
F (24) 6/17+
G (7) 29 Z5 (24 b) 20, 17, 15/20+
H (17) 20 (26) 9
(30) 18 (35) 24+
Z= 21 (17) 15,
10 Z6 (31) 46 (36 Y) 33 (19 Y1) 3 (41)=
Z1= 24 (11) 6 Z7 (30) 19 (34) 28 (23, 39)=
Z2= 31 (24) Y2 Y3 20 Z8 (34, 39)=
Z3= 33 (35 Y4) 44 (19-23) 24 (22) 6/17 (40) 1
(45, 50)=
Z4= 36 (28) 35 (32)=
Z5= 17, 26 Z9 (23) 42 Z10 (28) 22 (24, 24)=
Z6= 20 (31) 3 (19) 26 (36) 37 (24)=
Z7= 16 (11-17) 6 (18-22) 1 (13-18) 19 (27) 13 u, 31 (30) 4 (34)=
Z8= 18, 35 (38)=
Z9= 40 (26) 18 (25) 13 (20) 29 (24) 35 (31) 19
(30, 37)=
Z10= 12 (24, 24)=
Y (18) 38-32 (14) 27+
Y1 (18) 33-28 (13) 37 (19) 22+
Y2 (35) 24 (40) 35 (45) 44 (50) 6 (45) 1+
Y4 (19-23) 44, 35 (22) 27 (39) 49+
a (17) 1 (22) 32 (19) 6 (27) 21 (23) 16 (13) 16-11 (19) 7, 39+
b (25) 17, 26+
z= 33 (17) 1 (25) 34 (19) 28 (24) 28-23 (24-30) 29 (35) 18 (30) 45 (14) 23 (19) 14 (40) 28 (45) 6 (50) 12 (34)=
y= 21 (7) 33 (11) 19 (25) 17 (30) 12 (35) 7
(13/14, 40)=
x= 32? (25), 1(14, 14) =
w= 28 (14) 17, 10 (30) 23 (26) 18 (35)=
v= 17, 26 (30)=
u= 14 (31) 10 (36) 5 (17-22) 46 (30) 6 (27)
14 (23, 41)=
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
A38.
10 Z (27 a) 3 (12 A b) 17 (29 B C) 28 Z1, 5 (31 D) 26 (33) 21 (39) 49+
A (29) 34 (38) 5 (42) 37, 23+
B (31) 26 (36) 5 (28 E) 37, 46+
C (37) 22, 4+
D (34) 16/21 (40) 11 (45) 50+
E (38) 43/49 (41) 37+
Z= 3 (27) 29 (37) 47 (32 y) 10 (41) 36 (38)=
Z1= 4 (38) 31 (43) 39, 18 (33, 38)=
y (31) 10 (36) 5 (36-41) 36 (42) 37+
a (38) 3 (13) 4 (18) 13*, 43/49+ *Too 4-9 (27) 31 (43) 18+ or 3-14 (29) 28, 43+
b (13) 4 (19) 31/36 (38) 13 or 18+
|
CATEGORIE B |
|||||||
|
N° |
Auteurs |
Pays |
Gerrit. L de Bruijn |
Rimas Mackevicius |
Petr Shkludov |
Total |
Place |
|
13 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
77 |
85 |
65 |
152 |
1 |
|
45 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
69 |
55 |
80 |
136,50 |
2 |
|
29 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
73 |
75 |
48 |
134,50 |
3 |
|
46 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
64 |
80 |
60 |
134 |
4 |
|
15 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
65 |
80 |
57 |
133,50 |
5 |
|
38 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
68 |
65 |
53 |
125,50 |
6 |
|
9 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
75 |
55 |
40 |
112,50 |
7 |
|
6 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
63 |
45 |
54 |
108 |
8 |
|
35 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
53 |
62 |
34 |
101 |
9 |
|
24 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
54 |
55 |
32 |
97,50 |
10 |
|
7 |
A.Kaciuska |
Lituanie |
62 |
55 |
20 |
96 |
11 |
|
12 |
S.Rezel |
France |
66 |
25 |
50 |
95,50 |
12 |
|
18 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belarus |
47 |
55 |
30 |
89,50 |
13 |
|
21 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
48 |
50 |
28 |
87 |
14 |
|
17 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
40 |
25 |
48 |
76,50 |
15 |
|
36 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
38 |
35 |
34 |
71 |
16 |
|
30 |
A.Kaciuska |
Lituanie |
46 |
30 |
25 |
65,50 |
17 |
|
10 |
V.Shulga |
Belarus |
33 |
25 |
35 |
63 |
18 |
|
44 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
30 |
30 |
35 |
62,50 |
19 |
|
23 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
49 |
25 |
22 |
60,50 |
20 |
|
34 |
S.Rezel |
France |
50 |
20 |
25 |
60 |
21 |
|
31 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
43 |
20 |
25 |
56,50 |
22 |
|
43 |
V.Muliar |
Ukraine |
14 |
20 |
30 |
42 |
23 |
|
22 |
V.Muliar |
Ukraine |
3 |
20 |
10 |
21,50 |
24 |
|
1 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
2 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
3 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
4 |
J.Siozinys |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
5 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
8 |
F.Laurent |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
11 |
V.Bielauskas |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
14 |
A.Vermeulen |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
16 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
19 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
20 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
25 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
26 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
27 |
J.Siozinys |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
28 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
32 |
V.Shulga |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
33 |
V.Bieliauskas |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
37 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
39 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
40 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
41 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
42 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
B1 |
B2 |
B3 |
B4 |
B5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B6 |
B7 |
B8 |
B9 |
B10 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B11 |
B12 |
B13 |
B14 |
B15 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B16 |
B17 |
B18 |
B19 |
B20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B21 |
B22 |
B23 |
B24 |
B25 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B26 |
B27 |
B28 |
B29 |
B30 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B31 |
B32 |
B33 |
B34 |
B35 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B36 |
B37 |
B38 |
B39 |
B40 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B41 |
B42 |
B43 |
B44 |
B45 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B46 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Author solutions, but see also
PWCE. List of Eliminations. LISTE DEFINITIVE
Explication for the participants of the PWCE
B1.
VP 250 Z (46 A) 14 (31-37) 13 (37-41 B C) 20 (47) 24 Y (36 D) 5, 41, 15, 24+
A (37) 13 (42 E F) 5 (41-47) 37, 36 etc.+
B (46-41) 31, 5+
C (42) 5, 48+
D (47-41) 15. If (36) 5, 41, 24+ If (37-23) 5, 4+ If (47) 20 (36) 5, 4/41 etc.+
E (47) 31, 15, 24 (31) 5+
F (46) 31, 5 (31) 204, 26+
Z= 5? (37) 249 (42)=
Y= 15? (36) 13-4
(36-41) 13 (36) etc.=
Second
solution
16/46A/,4+ A/47/2,250+
B2.
31, 31, 38, 48 (22) 37+
Not
two thematic variants
B3.
VP 22 (46 A) 43-38 (361) 22-27 (47) 38-32, 42, 5+
A (47) 22-27 (361 B C) 43-32, 42, 46 (33) 32 (39) 49+
B (371) 42 (49) 32, 46+
C (15) 38 (47)
42, 46+
Second
solution
1.43-27/46/.33/46-41/.28+
1.16-27/46/.38/46-41/.11-16+
B4.
VP 24-8 (2x13 A) 30x44 (40x21), 16x49 (6-11)
49-44 (11-16) 44-49 (16-21) 49x16 (35-40) 16-11 (40-45) 11-50+
A (35x24) 8x11
(6x17) 16-32 (17-21) 32x16 (7-11) 16x7 (2x11) 38-32 (11-17) 32-27+
Anticipation / ressemblance
J.Sioozinys Championship of Novopolock 2004-48
A7.c7.d4.d8.g3.h4/c1.Da5.Df8.Dg5.Fe7
[a5, f8, g5 – c1 / d4, a7, c7, d8, g3, h4: fe7+ ]
B5.
VP 1 (239) 14 (38) 34 (42 A) 14-20, 29 (47 B) 24, 14+
B (48) 34, 34+
A (29) 7(43) 32 (49 C) 7-16+
C (48) 34, 34+
or (48) 38 (26) 42, 34, 34+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Strongly related endgame composition: 13,33,D29/6,24,25,D14 -/.
Weiss 19З4, Het Eindspel Td ed. (Moser, 1951): 24-19, 1 (З8) 34 etc.
B6.
VP 48 (32, A a) 41 (10, 38) 32, 43 (31) 49+
A (31, 39 B C) 28 Z1 (43) 48 (49) 44, 34 (10)
39 (30, 40) 20 (45) 50+
Z1= 48 (44) 28 (50) 6 (40, 30, 45)=
B (38) 21 Z2 (42) 37, 49 (36) 45-40, 19+
Z2= 25 (10) 26-48 (14) 3 (30, 42 Y1)=
Y1 (40, 42) 29+
C (10, 38) 21 Z3 Z4 (42) 37, 49+
Z3= 28 (40, 43)=
Z4= 48 (30 Y2, 40, 43)=
Y2 (29) 10 (34) 30, 15+
a (29) 14-37 Z5 (34) 25 (38) 39 (10, 42) 37, 28+
Z5= 43 (31) 46 (36) 37 (10, 40)=
B7.
VP 11-7 (37) 2 (20 A B) 19 (42) 14, 13, 47+
A (41) 19, 47+
B (32) Z 24 (20 C) 15 (41) Z1 20/29 (37 D) 47 (46) 41+
C (41) 19, 46+
D (46) 23+
Z= 16 (19) 38 (23) 29 (41)=
Z1= 10 (47)=
B8.
10-4 Z (27-31) 4x36 (1-7) 11x2 (25-30 A) 2x35 (32-38) 36-31 (37x26) 35-49 (38-42) 49-21 (26x17) 3x48+
Z= 5 (38) 41 (7, 43) 12 (30)=
A (38) 31, 16 (42) 16-21+
Second solution
Authors solution : 4/31/36/7/2/30A/35/38/31.49/42/21.48. Wins and 47/43a/42.49+
a) 372/30.24+ A)38/31.16/42/16-21+ Wins and 24/43/24-20.48
B9.
48 (25) 44-39, 9 (21 A) 3 (42) 29 (20 B) 4 (47 C) 36 (38) 20, 47+
A (20) 25 (21) 3 (42) 29 (47) 25-14+
B (48) 31, 29-12+
C (48) 25 (37) 31-48+
B10.
49 (4 A B C) 22, 20 (37, 37) 47+
A (21) 16 (37, 37) 47 (20 D 41) 32+
B (19, 37, 37) 26 (41) 37, 15 (37 E) 10+
C (37) 25, 33-39+
D (13) 16-38 (42) 20+
E (23) 20 (28) 42+
B11.
VP 44 (17 A) 35 (37 B) 38 (41) 20, 47 (22 C) 42
(27 a) 47 (50 D E) 39, 16/21+
A (27) 38, 48 (31 F G) 8 (20 H) 3 (50) 12+
B (50) 38 (47) 24, 25x3x38+
C (50) 39, 6/11+
D (32) 27 (50) 36+
E (31) 41 (37 I) 28 (50) 383+
F (20) 43 (50) 439 (45) 40+
G (50) 484, 3/8+
H (50) 24+
I (50) 47, 15/38 (37) 47+
a (28) 40 Z Z1, 48 Z2+
Z= (39) (32 Y Y1) 27 (50)=
Z1= 47 (33 Y2 Y3) 29 (50)=
Z2= 26 (32 Y4) 27(39)=
Y (50) 47+
Y1 (33) 29 (50) 423 (45) 34 (50) 6+
Y2 (32) 27(50) 36+
Y3 (50) 39+
Y4 (39) 32+
Draw
44/38.50/=
B12.
VP 8 Z (23) 21 (28, 30) 18 Z1 Z2 (35 A) 49 (16) 13 (12) 9 Z3 (21, 40) 49 (45) 40, 3 (18) 9 (23) 14 (29) 20 (33) 38 (40) 33 (45) 50+
A (34) 182, 16 (17) 7 (182) 40 (28) 49 (33) 43
(21, 39) 49+
Z= 29 (30) 25 (35) 24, 1 (17) 6 (21) 22 (40)=
Z1= 49 (34 Y) 44 (12) 18, 6 (40) 1 (45)=
Y (35) 18+ (VP)
Z2= 43 (35) 49 (12) 44 (16)=
Z3= 44 (18, 21) 17, 22 (40)=
B13.
4 z1 (36 A a) 12 Z1, 15 Z2 (29 B) 32 (34 C) 42 (39 C1 D) 16 (43 E) 49 (41) 37, 3+
A (21) 16 (36 F G) 43 (41) 32 (46) 5 (30 H) 9 Z3 (41) 46 (34) 4 (40 J) 28, 45+
B (39) 2 (41) 19+
C (13) 20 Z4 (34 b) 42 (41 D1) 46 (39) 33 Z5 Z6+
C1 (41) 46 (39) 33, 2+ or 29 (43) 38+
D (40) 33 (45) 50 (12) 19/5 (17) 6 (50) 19/5-28, 28+
D1 (40) 33 (45) 50 (18) 19/5 (22) 6 (50) 19/5-28, 28+
E1 (41) 37, 2+
E2 (44) 31, 2+
F1 (39) 27+
F2 (30) 27, 25 or 11 (38) 16 (42) 27, 25+
G (37) 15 z2 (39 c) 31 (44) 22+
H (38) 9 Z7 (41) 46 (42) 4(29) 41/32/19/5 (33) 28, 48+
J (38) 28 (40 K L) 15 (43) 39, 33 (45) 50 (39) 33/6+
K (42) 41 or 19 (40) 47 or 24 (48) 42, 45+
L (39) 44/50 (42) 28 (48) 37+
Z1= 15 (21) 16 (41)=
Z2= 10 (29) 15 (34) 2 (39) 30 (41 Z8) 43/48 (46)=
Z3= 15 (39) 29 (34) 40 (41) 46 (43)=
Z4= 32-14/5 (34) 47 (40) 33 (19) 45 (41)=
Z5= 23(19) 14/5 (44)=
Z6= 29(18) 12/1 (43)=
Z7= 15 (32)=
Z8 (44) 39, 47+
a1 (37) 15 (29) 38, 47 (21) 12/13 (27) 7/8/9 (32) 1/2/4+
a2 (29) 12, 36+
b (18) 15/19 (22) 5 (27) 19 (31) 32 (34) 26 (39 d) 16+
c (29) 38, 47+
d (40) 17 (45) 6 or 50+
z2= 43 (29)= [(41) 32 etc+, (42) 48 (47) 37 etc+]
z1= 5 (21 z3) 16 (30 z4) 5-32 (34) 11 (34-39) 13 (36) and Z7=
z3= (29) 19 z5 (21) 16 (34 z6) 19-32 (36) 11 (41 z7)=
z4 (39) 11 (43) 19, 26+
z5= 5-32 (21 z8) 16 (36)=
z6 (39) 28 (33) 2, 26+
z7 (34-39) 13 (38) 34 (41) 2+
z8 (38) 27, 33+
B14.
27, 43 (21) 16 (34) 43 (40 A) 35 (32) 27 (39) 49 (44) 490 (34) 30, 45+
A (38) 40 (34)
45+
Not
two thematic variants
B15.
3 (30 A B) 16 (48 C) 29 (26-31 D) 25 (48-37 E F) 42, 16-43, 26+
A (39) 45-12 (30 G H) 16 (31 C1) 11, 25+
B (48) 25 (37) 42, 45-34+
C (19) 8, 45-7+
C1 (19) 3-8, 12-7+
D (11) 2 (26-31 J) 30, 29-20 (14) 20(37) 47+
E (36) 29-34, 48 (41) 37+
F (11) 7 (48-37 D1) 42, 7-34, 26+
D1 (36) 29-34, 48, 37, 29 (37) 47+
G (28) 38-21+
H (50) 33+
J (48-31) 21, 12, 36+
B16.
18 (12 A) 17, 2 (24) 35 (11) 44 (16) 49 (30) 43 (35) 49+
A (22) 17, 15 (30 B) 33 (34) 44+
B (11) 33 (16) 38 (30) 43 (35) 49+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
B17.
3 (340 A) 20, 42 (37 B) 29 (26 C) 18+
A (38, 28, 340) 39 (45) 37 (29 a b c) 34 (50) 3-14
(5 D) 46+
B (40) 22 (45) 50 (28 d) 6 (50) 423 (28) 33 (37) 47+
C (34) 25 (40) 39 (45) 50+
D (46) 5+
a (50) 46+
b (40) 19+
c (30) 28+
d (29) 24/15 (37) 47+
B18.
4 (39 A A1 B C) 36 (33 D) 46-41 (26 E) 46 (43/44) 31, 48/50+
A (36) 15 (34 F) 16 (39 G) 49+
A1 (27) 15 (34 H) 16 (39 I) 49+
B (38) 36 (27) 34 (42) 37+
C (34) 36 (40) 27, 35+
D (43/44) 27, 48/49+
E (43/44) 27, 48/50+
F (27) 20 (31) 32 (34) 26 (39 J) 16 (41 K) 37+
G (40) 11 (45) 50+
H (36) 20 (31) 32 (34) 26+
I (40) 11 (45) 50+
J (40) 17 (45) 50+
K (44) 31+
B19.
33 Z1 Z2 (27) 7 (32) 1 (37 A B) 293 Z3 (41 B C) 28 (46 D E) 238, 45+
A (38, 44) 33 (49) 44+
B (42, 44) 33 (49) 44+
C (45) 47 (50) 6 (45) 1+
D (47) 33, 45+
E (44) 50 Z4 (47) 33+
Z1= 7 (27, 44) 1 (49)=
Z2= 28 (27) 7 (32, 44)=
Z3= 28 (42 Y1) 33 (44) 47/50 (49/47)=
Z4= 46 (49)=
Y1 (44) 50 (41)
29-23 (47) 33+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Ant.3.83 NN 1886
16.35/18.29.D3
B20.
VP 4 (36 A) 31, 16 (7 B C D) 35 (43) 38, 24 (37) 47+
A (35) 36 (44) 40, 40, 18+
B (44) 29-7, 49+
C (35) 45 (44 E) 11 (50) 6 (7) 1 (40) 45+
D (34) 40 (7) 1 (44) 40+
E (7) 1 (44) 11 (49) 44, 45+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
B21.
3 (1-7 A a) 1 (43) 31 (39 B C b) 13 Z Z1 (7 D E F) 40 (49 G) 3-8, 8-2+
A (43) 3-8, 7, 49+
a (6) 12-8, 3-21+
B (49) 40, 13+
C (38) 34 (49) 40, 13+
b (48) 1-12+
D (48) 31, 1-12+
E (44) 7, 17+
F (49) 40+
G (48) 31, 40-12+
Z= 27 (8)=
Z1= 4 (7)=
B22.
10-5 (33x15 A) 25-20 (15x33) 5-32 (38x27) 36x50+
A (33x20) 25x14 (38x43 B) 36-47 (43-49) 47-42 (48x10) 5x46+
B (38-42) 36-47 (42-48) 47-42 (48x10) 5x46+
B23.
47 (39 A B) 21, 42+
A (40) 26, 27, 17+
B (16-21) 3 (26) 21, 27+
B24.
2 (31 A) 16 (45 B C) 32-28, 38. If (50) 38-33 (28) 33 (37) 47+ If (37) 32, 50+ If (36) 32 (50) 28, 28+
A (45) 11 (31) 27, 19+
B (36) 44, 27, 19...+
C (44, 36) 32-27 (29 D E) 27-22 (41) 28 (47) 38+
D (41) 28, 46+
E (28) 17 (41) 26 etc+
B25.
40, 3, 16+
Not
two thematic variants
B26.
18-9 (7,30,42 A) 14 (39 B C) 37, 25 (36) 48 (41) 37, 24 (37) 47+
A (39) 27 (393) 31 (49) 17 (49-43) 37 (34) 33, 48+
B (38) 37, 26, (36) 49 (42) 48 (41) 37+
C (47) 13 (38)
3-9 (41) 46 (43) 4 (49) 32+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Lietuva-2003, B-18
W.Riemens
S.Maltsev 1977
2.25.28.32/9.11.D40
B27.
38-32 (27x38) 29x18 (40x29 A) 18x34 (1x40) 45x26 (35-40) 26-17 (40-45) 50+
A (1x29) 34x26 (40-44) 26-17 (44-49 B) 17-44+
B (44-50) 17-6+
Anticipation / ressemblance
5 Чемпионат Новополоцка, 2004, №49 И. Шёжинис [a1, f4, h2 – b2 / b8, e5 – d6, e7, g3, h4: c3, c7+ ]
J.Siozinys.Championship of Novopolock
D6.e7.g3.h4.Db8.De5/b2.Da1.Df4.Dh2 Sol : c3.c7
B28.
VP 20 (33) 26 (36) 37 (39) 47 (44 A B) 26-31, 32, 50+
A (43) 371, 38, 42 (31, 38) 48+
B (41) 46 (44) 37(49 C) 38, 37+
C (50) 33, 37+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Strongly related endgame composition: 10,29,36,38/9,37,D26 - V Gusev, Dambrete
8-1977 + Antol. 3-545
B29.
35 (22) 49 (36 A) 8 Z1 (41) 37, 13 (28 B) 19 (15)
14-Z2 Z3 Z4 (20, 38 C) 33 (29 D)
14 (28-33 E) 20 (34) 38 (40) 33 (45) 50+
A (18) 16 Z5 (28 F) 7 see Z5 (23) 34 (36 G) 30 (33, 41) 37, 24 (28) 38 (33) 4+
B (27) 36 Z6 (37) 47 (14) 39-33 (20) 29 (25) 24+
C (37) 33, 26+
D (39) 32+
E (29-33) 32 (39) 49+
F (23) 27 Z7 (37) 34, 25+
G (14) 12 ! (32) 21 (32-37) 3, 25, 26.
Z1= 3 (41) 37, 9 (28 Y1)=
Y1 (27) 36 (37) 47 (14) 39-33 (20) 29 (25) 24+
Z2= 5 (20) 10 (25 Y2) 14 (30) 19 (34, 33) 37 (39)=
Y2 (24) 15 (30) 42+
Z3= 34 (20) 29 (24)=
Z4= 24 (37) 19 (33)=
Z5= 21 (28 Y4) 17 (36 Y5, 41)=
Y4 (23) 27 (37) 34, 25+
Y5 (32) 21 (32-37) 3, 25 (30) 26 (22) 21 (28) 38 (33) 4+
Z6= 31 (38) 4 (15) 31 (20) 26 (25 Y6) 37 (30) 48 (43)=
Y6 (24) 33, 8 (30) 35 (34) 44 (40) 35+
Z7= 7 (36 Y3, 41)=
Y3 (22-28) 34 (36) 30 (33, 41) 37, 24 (28) 38 (15) 24 (32) 42 (20, 37) 47+
B30.
VP 48 (20 A B) Z 11, 34, Z1 21 (39) 49+
A (49) 9, 9-13+
B (38) Z2 34, 3 (42) 11, 48+
Z= 34, 3 (39)=
Z1= 26 (39 Y)=
Z2= 11, 34, 26 (43)=
Y (38) 48+
B31.
32 (37) 3 (43 A) 42, 49+
A (41) 36 (42 B) 47 (48) 30, 47-20+
B (43) 49 (48) 31, 49-21+
B32.
44 (35 A) 50 (40 B) 45 (34, 34) 39, 48+
A (7) 35 (34, 34) 49 (33) 39, 1+
B (34, 34) 45 (39, 40) 50, 39 (7) 6 (34) 1+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
B33.
VP 5-10 (43 A B) 15 (10) 31 (27 C) 40, 31 (38) 48+
A (32) 27 (22) 29 (41) 23+
B (31) 15, 44/50 (37 D E) 28, 46+
C (32) 16, 5/19+
D (28) 17 (37) 26 (361) 48 Z (47) 42 (41) 37+
E (41) 28, 47+
Y (46) 37+
Not
two thematic variants
B34.
VP 5 (26) 2-19 (3) 472 (25 A) 15-38 (44) 43, 50+
A (43/44) 5-14, 19-24, 49/50+
B35.
16 z1 z2 (21 a b) 2 z3 (12 A) 24 (39 B) 23-18, 42
(36 C) 31, 26 (32 D D1) 27+
A (36) 38 (26 E1 c) 16 (41) 32 (46 E) 28+
B (36) 31 Z1, 47 (32) 19 (37) 14 (27) 10 Z2 (32) 5
(18 F) 20/15 (23) 28, 14/10 (41/42) 46/48+
C (26) 37+
D (28) 44/50 (32) 33 (37) 47+
D1 (44) 49 (31) 32/38+
E (47) 41, 23-18+
E1 (32) 16 (41) 32 (47) 15 (36) 4 (47) 41, 23-18+
F (38) 7/1 (42) 37+
Z1= 38 (32 Z3) 16 (41) 32 (46 Z4) 28 (17)=
Z2= 9 (32) 3 (41)=
Z3 (31) 16 (37) 10 (17 Z5 Z6) 18 (42) 37, 2
(41 Z7 z4) 12, 47+
Z4 (47) 38+
Z5 (36-41) 32, 46+
Z6 (42) 18, 48 (41) 37+
Z7 (22) 27, 19+
a (36) 2 (41) 2-24 or 4-15 etc+
b1 (38) 43/48 (37) 31, 27 etc+
b2 (36) 31, 3 or 32 etc+
c (31) 16 (37) 31 (26) 32 or 38 etc+
z1= 2 (36) 12 (41)=
z2= 15 (36) 3 (41)=
z3= 15 (39) 2 (12 z5) 30 (36) 43 (31) 16 (41)=
z4 (21) 16 (26) 32+
z5= (36) 43(31) 16 (41) 2 (46) 2-19 (31-37)
47(46-41)=
B36.
47-42 (38 A B C) 33 (27 D) 28 (15-20) 25 (31) 23 (37) 19+
A (15-20) 43 (27) 49 (24 E) 42-38+
B (26) 38, 9+
C (27) 38+
D (26) 29 (14-20) 42 (31) 26 (24) 20+
E (19) 42-38, 25 (32) 20 (37) 47+
B37.
17 (39 A) 2 (11 B C) 16 (8 D) 3 (44) 12 (49) 17-11
(44 E) 6 (35 F) 1 (49 G H) 6 (35) 6-11 (30) 8, 7+
A (40) 35 (45) 44 (50 I) 40, 8, 16+
B (43) 11, 48+
C (44) 11, 49+
D (44) 8+
E (35) 8, 7+
F (49) 1 (44) 6+
G (30) 8, 7+
H (44) 6+
I (8-50) 12+
Second
solution
24+ 30+ 35+
B38.
28 (34 A) 29 (32 B C a b) 26 (41 c) 12, 23, 46+
A (29) 34, 1 (32) 26 (41) 37, 29 (37) 47+
B (37) 46 (32) 1 (41) 6 (47) 33 (41/36) 28/22+
C (11) 6 (32 D E) 28, 23+
D (37) 22, 23, 46+
E (41) 22, 23, 47+
a (12) 19/5 (17) 50 (32 d) 3 (41) 28 (47) 284+
b (41, 32, 37) 293/50 (41/42) 50+
c (12) 8/3 (41) 17(47) 33+
d (37) 46 (32) 11/6 (41) 45+
B39.
14 Z1 Z2 (32 A) 37 (50 B) 37-23, 44, 6 (44 C)
50 (42 D) 37+
A (33) 1-40, 25 (33-39) 24 (40) 21 (44) 35 (50) 6 (45) 1 (50) 21-12 (28) 44, 6+
B (43) 32 (49 E F) 2, 11+
C (42/43) 23-28, 47/48+
D (43) 39+
E (48) 43, 44, 6+
F (50) 49, 35-40 (28) 49-44, 6+
Z1= 25 (50) 48 (32) 6 (37, 43)=
Z2= 1-40, 25
(32) 48 (37, 43)=
Second
solution
34/50/.31/45/.34-48+ normal endgame
B40.
VP 43 (8 A) 16 (30) 29+
A (18) 14,
35-30, 6+
Anticipation /ressemblance
11,12,25, K 3 / 19,35, K 38.
Author - Vasilij GREBENKO.
Publication: web - site "Shashki v Rossiji" (web - site Mr.A.Kandaurov), february, 2005.
B41.
VP 26 (7-12 A B C) 7 (3) 1 (25) 9, 1-12 (21 D) 25+
A (3) 18-12 (18) 25+
B (34) 1 (32) 10 (38) 15 (43 E) 29, 48+
C (6) 17, 25+
D (17) 35 (33 F) 30 (38) 48+
E (39) 42/47 (43/44) 33 (48/49) 39/44+
F (32) 24 (37)
47+
Autre
reason
XIII
Championnat de Biélorussie 2006
B42.
4 (33-38 A B a) 2 Z (31 C C1) 36 (43 D E) 34 Z1
(49 F) 40, 36-13+
A (31) 36 (33-38 b) 22 (37) 21+
B (39) 11+
C (43) 11+
C1 (37) 11+
D (21) 26 (43) Z2 47 (49 G) 38, 48+
E (37) 36-13 (38-42) 29 (48) 34+
F (48) 36-13+
G (38) 33 (49) 21, 33-11+
a (32-38) 29, 15+
b (328) 26 (21) 39 (42) 47 (48) 25+ or 7-34+
Z= 27, 1 (27) 17 (27-31)=
Z1= 36-13 (21)=
Z2= 30 (48 z1) 25 (37)=
z1 (49) 43, 37+
Second
solution
5/2-328/.32.17+ 5/338/.41/46+
B43.
20-14 (23x5 A) 37-48 (26x37x28) 48x34x23x46+
A (23x10) 37-48 (26x28) 48x5 (28-33) 5-32 (33-39) 32-49+
B44.
39 Z (43 A) 37 (14 B) 36x26x3x49+
A (44) 5, 49+
B (42) 26+
Z= 37 (42) 30 (34)=
B45.
2 Z z y (26-31 A) 33! Z1 Z2 x w (12 a b c) 19 Z3 (17) 11! (13 B) 8 (36) 26 (41) 37, 7 (22 C) 16 Z4 (31 D) 38 (37 E F) 47 (27) 43-38 (42 G) 36+
A (27-31) 16 Z5 (12 A1 d e) 32 Z6 v (36) 43-38 u t (17 H f) 28 (31) 5/10 Z7 (23) 3 Z8 (19) 26 (41) 14 (47) 26-3+
A1 (36) 32 (12) 43-38 etc.
B (36) 13! (23 J) 4 (32 g) 10 Z9 Z10 (38) 10x32 Z11 (49) 11-16, 32+
C (23) 34/45 (37) 18 (31 I) 36 (42) 38, 27 (39) 49+
D (28) 38, 49+
E (27) 21/16 (37) 32, 38+
F (36) 47 (27 K) 43-38 (31) 32+
G (31) 36+
H (19) 17(31) 12 Z12, 1 (11) 6 Z13 (16) 28 (21) 5/23 (27) 5-32+
J (32) 38 (41) 28 (47) 15 (36) 41 Z14, 43-38+
I (32) 23+
K (28) 438+
Z= 17? (26-31) 20 (37!) 47 (23) 43-38 Z15 (32) 27 (29) 2/8 (41/42)=
Z1= 38? (36 Y h) 16 (32) 27 (23 Y1 Y2) 17 (14*) 20 (41) 47 (29!) 2/8 (46/47)=
*One may too (19) 20 (41) 47 (29)=
Z2= 16? (36) 32 (14) 5/10 (19) 3 (41) 28 (47)=
Z3= 24? (17 Y3) 11 (37!) 47 Z16 Z17 (23) 43-38 (32) 27 (29) 3 (41/42)=
Z4= 23? (28) 5/19 (31) 38, 49 (37)=
Z5= 28? (12! Y4) 19 (13 j) 17 (22) 46 Z18, 38 (17 Y5) 38-32 Z19 (21) 41 Z20 (36) 37 (31) 3/17 (41)=
Z6= 2? (36) 19 (31) 1 Z21 (14) 5/10 (23) 3/8 (41)=
Z7= 46? (22) 6 (19 Y6) 3 (41) 3-17 (37) 26 (46/47)=
Z8= 2/8? (14) 26 (41) 19 (47)=
Z9= 31?, 28 (38)
21 (32)=
Z10= 28? (38)
32 (41) 19 (47) 15 (36) 4 (47) 15 (36)=
Z11= 43x32 (41) 28 (47)=
Z12= 26 (37) 42 (41) 32 (22) 28 (47) 15 (36)=
Z13= 23 (17) 5/19 (22) 23 (28)=
Z14= 5/10 (27) 14 (49)=
Z15= 2 (32) 28, 43-38 (42) 41, 19 (38/39)=
Z16= 28 (23) 3 (41) 14 (46) 13 (5/10)=
Z17= 13 (31) 36 (42) 4 (47/48)=
Z18= 8, 19 (36) 46 (31) 5/23 (38, 37, 47)=
Z19= 41 (36 Y7) 46 (31) 19 (22) 33 (28 Y8) 26 (41)=
Z20= 28 (27) 23 (36) 19 (261) 13/14 (37, 41)=
Z21= 38 (22) 28 (17) 6 (13) 8 (41) 19 (46) 5 (31-37)=
Y (37?) 16! (32) 27 (23) 28, 41/46 (12) 37 (17) 26 (22) 3 (14) 20 (28) 15+
Y1 (12?) 28 (17) 6/11 (19) 17! (18-23 Y9 Y10) 26
(41 i) 37, 4 (29) 10 (24) 15+
Y2 (19?) 27-22, 26 (41) 37, 33(37) 47+
Y3 (36?) 47 (23) 24-42! (32 Y11) 48 (18) 43-38, 3 (29) 24 (41) 13, 46+
Y4 (36?) 5 (14) 3 (19) 24 (41) 14 (47) 15 (36) 41,
43-38+
Y5 (36?)
38-32/33 (31) 32-28 (16) 22 (21) 23 (27) 7/1, 23+
Y6 (14?) 5/10 (19) 26 (41) 26-17+
Y7 (22?) 36 (37) 4 (41) 10 (46) 5 (31) 382, 26+
Y8 (27?) 33-28 (41) 22, 46+
Y9 (19-23) 26 (28) 22 (27) 3 (41) 37+
Y10 (22) 3 (41) 26+
Y11 (18) 43-38 (28) 48 (28-32) 34/25, 48 (32 Y12) 43 (23 Y13, 29) 24 (41) 10 (47) 15+
Y12 (14) 37(20) 15 (31) 26 (41) 37, 4 (23) 15+
Y13 (37) 48 (37-41) 31, 4+
a (14) 16 (139 k) 38! (36) 47 (19-23 l m) 438 (12 n) 39 (20) 25 (24) 9 (239) 31, 33, 20 (32) 3 (18) 9 (23) 20+
b (19) 24 (36) 47 (23) 43-38 (31) 15 (14) 32 (37) 41(29) 9, 36+
c (36/37) 20+
d (14) 21, 36 (20 o p ) 31 (24) 39 (30) 27! (35 q)
34 (23) 9 (29) 23 (40) 3 (45) 17 (50) 6 (45) 1+
e (37) 21, 41/46 (22) 32 (12) 38/39 (17) 33 (14) 5/10 (27) 37 (22) 29 (18) 24+
f (31) 5/10 (17) 28 (22) 6 (14) 26 (41) 26-17 (18) 28 (46) 38-32 (22) 17+
g (29) 31, 7 (32) 34/45 (37) 23 (42) 38+
h (23) 16 (19) 32 (36) 6-33 (9-13) 15 (18) 10 (12) 46 (22) 33 (18) 5 (27) 33-28, 14/10+
j (23) 22, 36+
i (29) 22 (24) 17/18 (41) 37, 49+
k (32) 38 (36) 47(14-19) 43-38 (12 r) 29 (19-23) 15 (17) 41, 38-33 (24 s) 11 (19) 33+
l (12) 43-38 (18-23) 22 (20) 31, 32, 1/7+
m (13) 43-38 (19-23) 44 (29) 40 (33) 1/12, 27+
n (19) 17 (29) 3 (34) 9 (18-23) 31, 32, 40/45 (28) 29+
o (12) 41(13-19) 28 (18-23) 33 (18) 43-38+
p (14-19) 41 (24) 14 (30) 39 (12) 28+
q (12) 34!, 21+
r (19-23) 11 (29) 39 (23) 48 (18) 31, 32, 2+
s (20) 21/26+
z= 33 (27-31) 47 (36) 1 (12) 6 (31) 43-38 (23) 39 (17!) 6/11 (37) 32, 33 (19) 15 (29) 4 (41)=
y= 38? (27-31!) 2 (36) 28 (12!) 19 (23) 14, 49 (41)=
x= 28? (36) 46 (22) 38 (14!) 5/10 (19!) 5x28x3 (32) 27 (41) 19 (47)=
w= 6-39? (19!) 24 (36) 47 (32) 30 (13) 2/8 (38) 1/12 (41)=
v= 43-38? (14!) 21, 36 (20) 31 (17) 32 (25) 48 (19) 34 (18-22) 48 (21) 26 (21-27) 21 (28 or 30)=
u= 6-28? (17) 6 (31!) 6-28 (22) 6 (19) 3 (41 or 37)=
t= 46 ? (31) 5/10 (17) 28 (22) 6/17 (37) 46 (19) 3 (41) 28 (47)=
B46.
16-38 Z Z1 Z2 (19 A B b) 39 z (17) 49 y (21 B C) 16 (29 D) 49 Z3 (29-33) 34 (23 E F) 43 Z4 (39) 48, 25 (33 G) 14 (29) 20+
A (17) 24 x (22 H) 8 (29 J I) 21 Z5 Z6 (34 K L) 43, 49 (33) 16+
B (24) 35 (24-29) 34+
C (29) 34+
D (24) 49 Z7 (30) 38 (35) 34+
E (39) 43 (32) 38+
F (24) 35 (39) 32/46+
G (32) 20+
H (18) 24-38 (18-22) 39 (29) 20/24 (27 H1) 14 Z8 Z9 (27-32) 3 (21) 26 (38) 48 (43) 37+
H1 (32) 14 etc.+
J (27) 26 (29) 48 (34 M N) 39 Z10+
I (32) 26 (29) 48 (33) 38+
K (28-33) 26 Z11 (34 O) 38+
L (29-33) 16+
M (28-33) 38+
N (28-32) 38+
O (27) 48 (32 N1) 38 (43) 6/28+
N1 (34) 38+
Z= 11 (32) 28 (38, 49)=
Z1= 21 (12-18) 21-38 (22) 39 (19) 49 (24) 40 (24-29) 45 (29-33 Y, 44)=
Z2= 2 (13-18) 24 (32 Y1) 42 (17 Y2 Y3) 48 (21) 26 (28 Y4) 29 (37) 47 (33)=
Z3= 21 (24) 38 (28-33) 28 (34, 39)=
Z4= 27/16 (29, 39) 28 (44)=
Z5= 26 (34) 31 (39 Y5) 34 (32) 33=
Z6= 12 (32 Y6) 40 (37) 23 (42) 38, 38 (38)=
Z7= 7 (23-29) 40 (32) 35 (38, 42)=
Z8= 3 (28-32) 26 (38) 37 (32, 42)=
Z9= 25 (21 Y7) 33, 43 (31, 37)=
Z10= 38 (31 Y8) 26 Z12 (32, 39)=
Z11= 12 (27/28) 40 (39 Y9, 32/31)=
Z12= 30/25 (33, 37)=
Y (27) 39-34, 31/36 (33) 27 (39) 49+
Y1 (22) 24-38 (17) 39+. See A-variant.
Y2 (28) 48 (22) 38, 7 (32 Y10) 11 (27) 16+
Y3 (22) 48 (27 Y11) 38, 1/7 (32) 29 (37) 47+
Y4 (27) 48 (22) 38, 7 (31) 11 (36) 28+
Y5 (32) 40/45 (37) 23 (42) 38+
Y6 (27) 40 (31) 35 (36) 19 (33) 37 or 46+
Y7 (28-32) 14 (38) 3 (21) 26 (32) 31+
Y8 (40) 33, 45 (32) 29 (37) 47+
Y9 (32) 44 (33-38) 49 (42) 38+
Y10 (33) 16+
Y11 (18) 38, 6/17+
a (12-18) 39
(22) 49 (18 c) 38 (29) 20/24 (27) 25 (31) 33, 26+
b (13-18) 15/20 (22) 15-38 (17) 39+, like in H-variant.
c (29) 34, 2+ or 2: 38 (27) 8 (31) 26 (36) 37+
z= 21 (32) 24 (37) 47 (29, 41)=
y= 34 (24) 20 (32) 14 (29)=
x= 39 (18) 34 w (17-22) 21 (33) 16 (23-28) 49 (23) 16 (29) 32 (27) 21 (38/39)=
w= 20 (32) 14 (28) 25 (38) 20 (33) 28 (23)=
|
CATEGORIE C |
|||||||
|
N° |
Auteurs |
Pays |
Gerrit. L de Bruijn |
Rimas Mackevicius |
Petr Shkludov |
Total |
Place |
|
38 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
85 |
25 |
77 |
132 |
1 |
|
37 |
A.Fedoruk |
Russie |
52 |
70 |
65 |
126 |
2 |
|
28 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
58 |
52 |
32 |
97 |
3 |
|
18 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
37 |
60 |
34 |
84 |
4 |
|
25 |
A.Tavernier |
France |
41 |
57 |
28 |
83,50 |
5 |
|
15 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
23 |
45 |
35 |
69 |
6 |
|
11 |
V.Shulga |
Belarus |
24 |
55 |
27 |
66,50 |
7 |
|
26 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
51 |
25 |
24 |
62,50 |
8 |
|
34 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
16 |
40 |
30 |
58 |
9 |
|
27 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
14 |
40 |
30 |
57 |
10 |
|
7 |
J.Bus |
Pays-Bas |
36 |
18 |
18 |
45 |
11 |
|
21 |
M.Fedorov |
Ukraine |
2 |
24 |
28 |
39 |
12 |
|
16 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
3 |
20 |
28 |
35,50 |
13 |
|
8 |
A.Kaciuska |
Lituanie |
14 |
16 |
12 |
28 |
14 |
|
30 |
S.Ustianov |
Ukraine |
8 |
4 |
4 |
10 |
15 |
|
1 |
J.C.Patry |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
2 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
3 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
4 |
J.L.Besson |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
5 |
J.Siozinys |
Lituanie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
6 |
ATavernier |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
9 |
F.Laurent |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
10 |
M.Stanovskij |
Allemagne |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
12 |
J.Bastiaannet |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
13 |
A.Vermeulen |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
14 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
17 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
19 |
L.Witoshkin |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
20 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
22 |
R.Outters |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
23 |
W.Riemens |
Pays-Bas |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
24 |
J.L.Besson |
France |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
29 |
V.Trofimenko |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
31 |
M.Tsvetov |
Israel |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
32 |
K.Malashkevitch |
Belaruss |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
33 |
W.Grebenko |
Belarus |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
35 |
A.Katukha |
Ukraine |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
36 |
M.Fedorov |
Russie |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
C1 |
C2 |
C3 |
C4 |
C5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C6 |
C7 |
C8 |
C9 |
C10 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C11 |
C12 |
C13 |
C14 |
C15 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C16 |
C17 |
C18 |
C19 |
C20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C21 |
C22 |
C23 |
C24 |
C25 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C26 |
C27 |
C28 |
C29 |
C30 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C31 |
C32 |
C33 |
C34 |
C35 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C36 |
C37 |
C38 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Author solutions, but see also
PWCE. List of Eliminations. LISTE DEFINITIVE
Explication for the participants of the PWCE
C1.
VP 15 Z Y (28 A B) 15-24 X (13 C) 8 (33) 9 W (38 D) 8-3. If (42) 20, 47+ If (43) 20, 48+ If (30) 25 (35) 48 (40) 17 (45) 50+
A (27) 15-24 V (20, 30) 4 (14 E F) 36 (34) 41+
B (13) 4 (18) 24 (20, 30) 33 (34/35, 23) 10 (28) 33 etc+
C (20, 30) 26 (35) 4 (14) 4-31 (37) 42 (40) 17 (32) 6 (19) 11 (23) 6 (45) 50 (28) 6 (50) 42-33 (28) 33 (37) 47+
D (37) 19 (42) 37, 36+
E (38) 42x35+
F (35) 36 (40) 22 etc+
Z= 23? (28, 30) 38, 49 (34/35)=
Y= 24? (28) 35 (20, 37) 47 (33, 41/42)=
X= 4? (37)=
W= 3? (37)=
V= 4? (38)=
Second
solution
23+
C2.
29, 31, 37, 37+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
C3.
VP 32 (30 A) 23 (38 B) 50 (40) 45 (42) 34, 47+
A (29) 11 (294) 23 (38) 50 (42) 40, 47+
B (40) 45 (38 C) 50 (42) 34, 47+
C (35) 34, 25 (40) 39 (45) 50+
Other reason
Anticipation / ressemblanceОnlу part оf several endgame compositions, аll based оn 24, 29, 30, 39/D2, D32 - М. Shelomentsev, Bulletin Central Chess Сlub USSR 2-1958
No possible last move (3.1.3)
C4.
3-14 (36-18 A B) [if (36-31) 6-22; if (36-47) 14-20;
if (25-30) 14-41] 6-1 (18-13 C) 1-40 (13-35)
If [if (13-4) 40-35; if (13-8) 40-35; if (13-2) 14-5;
if (13-36) 40-18] 40-49 (35-13) [if (35-30) 14-5; if ( 35-8) 49-35; if (35-2) 14-5; if (25-30) 14-23] 14-5 (13-4)
[if (13-36) 5-41; if (13-35) 15-33; if (13-2) 49-16
(2-35) 15-29] 15-47 (4-36) 49-38 (25-30) 5-10 (30-34) 10-4.
A (36-13) 14-5 (13-2) [If (13-36) 5-41; (13-35) 6-28 (35-2) 28-32 (2-16) 32-49 (16-2) 49-16; (13-4) 15-47 (4-36) 6-33] 6-44 (2-16) If (2-35) 44-49.
44-49 (16-2) 49-16 (2-35) 15-29 (25-30) 16-49.
B (36-4) 15-47
(4-13) [If (4-18) 6-1] 14-5 (13-2);
[If (13-35) 6-28 (35-2) 28-32 (2-16) 32-49 (16-2) 49-16; If(13-36) 6-33 (25-30)
5-10 (30-34) 10-4]
6-44 (2-16) 44-49 (16-2) 49-16 (2-35) 47-29.
C (18-4) 15-47 (4-13) 1-40 (13-35)
[If (13-4) 14-10; if (13-30) 14-5 etc; if (13-8) 40-35;
if (13-2) 14-5] 40-49 (35-13)
[If (35-8) 49-35; if (25-30) 47-29; if (35-30) 14-5;
If (35-2) 14-5 (2-35) 47-33] 14-5 (13-36) [if (13-35) 47-33; if (13-2) 49-16 (2-35) 47-29] 49-38 (25-30) 5-10 (30-34) 10-4.
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
C5.
2-13 (31x22 A) 13x9 (4x31) 36x4+
A (4x22) 27x38 (5-10 B) 36x15 (37-41) 38-32
(41-46 C) 32x5+
B (37-42) 36x22+
C (41-47)
32-38+
Not
two thematic variants
C6.
VP 3 (30 A) 3-17 (48) 18-31 (21) 3 (37 B) 30 (26) 48+
A (48) 25 (21) 24 (37) 42, 18-34+
B (24) 30 (26 C) 48+
C (25) 48+
Anticipation /ressemblance
Very strongly related endgame composition:
16, 19,D43/8,D18,D26 –
К. Khalyetsky, Shashki, 10-1979 + Antol. IV-930
C7.
VP 26-37 Z1 (15-20) 30 Z3 (31, 25) 24 Z4 (8,14)
15 (7 A, 12) 15 (17) 42 (21) 26 (27) 3 (20 B) 25 (32) 20 (37) 47.
A (19, 23) 22 (29) 39 (7) 6 (34) 1 (40) 45+
B (19) 9 (32) 4 (23 C) 15+
C (38) 10+
Z1= 43 (15-20) 21 Z2 (8, 25, 14) 37 (7) 23 (11) 28 (16) 32 (20 Y1, 21)=
Y1 (15) 5 (20) 32 (24) 38 (30) 43 (35) 49+
Z2= 16 (8, 25, 14) 32 (7)=
Z3= 28 (25) 41 (6 Y2 Y3) 46 (11) 41 (31, 8, 14) 28 (16) 32 (20 Y1, 21)=
Y2 (32) 28 (30, 14) 23 (6) 28+
Y3 (31, 8 14) 23+
Z4= 34 (30 Y4, 14) 37 (7) 23 (11) 28 (16) 32
(20, 21)=
Y4 (8, 14) 23 (6) 28+
C8.
VP 45 (30 A) 8 (38 a) 7 (42) 11, 48+
A (37) 23+
a (37) 19 (42) 37, 23+ or 23 (42) 37+
C9.
4-36 Z (37-42 A B) 36-47 (32-38 C) 35-30 Z2 (25x34) 6-39 (34x43) 44-49+
A (32-38) 36-18 Z1 (37-42) 6/44-33 (29) 34 (30) 47+
Z1= 47 (41) 36 (26)=
B (48-42) 47 (15) 44-17 (41) 36 (42) 21+
C (37) 29+
Z= 6-1 (25-30) 19 (37-42)=
Z2= If 44-49 (34) 32 (42-48) 1 (34-39)=
If 6-17 (34) D=
D (25-30) 24 (25) 26 (42-48) 24x42 (37) 48 (3) 20 (25) 39 (43) 25+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
C10.
45-18 (43 A) 18-13 (38 B C D) 34 (49 E) 40, 2+
A (37) 31, 21+
B (48) 31, 3+
C (49) 40, 2+
D (37) 31, 21+
E (48) 2+
Not two thematic variants
Other reason
C11.
15 (38 A B C) 50 (42) 34, 47+
A (35) 38 (44) 33+
B (25) 38 (44) 40, 29+
C (24) 38 (44) 40, 29+
C12.
13-18 (24 A a) 4 Z1 (30 B C) 25 (40 B1) 34, 15 (9) 20 Z2 (34 D) 42 (39 D1 E1) 16 (43F) 49 (41) 37, 4+
A (38) 49 (40 G
H) 45 Z3 (41) 18/45-23 (47) 45/23-29, 35+
B (38) 49 (30 b) 25 (41) 14 (47) 38, 18 (9) 4 (40) 22 (45) 50+
B1 (38) 49 Z4 (41) 14 (47) 38, 18 (9) 4 (40) 22 (45) 50+
C (40) 45 (38) 43/49 (9 G1) 30 (41) 30-34+
D (13) 15 Z2 (34 c) 42 (41 E) 46 (39) 33 Z5 Z6+
D1 (41) 46 (39) 33, 3 or 29 (43) 38, 3+
E1 (40) 33 (45) 50 (14) 10/5+
E (40) 33 (45) 50 (18) 19/5 (22) 6 (50) 19/5-28, 28+
F1 (41) 37, 3+
F2 (44) 31+
G (9) 4 (41) 32 (47) 41, 34-18 (9) 18+
G1 (41) 32 (47) 41, 45-18 (13) 18 or 44 (46) 9, 29, 5+
H (41) 18 or 34-23 (47) 29, 18 or 23 or 34-40+
Z1= 37 (38) 34-48 (30) 25 (40) 45 (9) 3 (43 Z7) 34 (49 Z8)=
Z2= 32, 10/5 or 14/5 (34) 47 (40) 33 (14 or 19) 45 (41)=
Z3= 35 (8 Z9) 2 (24) 35 (41) =
Z4= 43 (41) 14 (40) 46 (45)=
Z5= 23 (19) 14/5 (44)=
Z6= 29 (18) 12/1 (43)=
Z7 (41) 46 (43) 45-12+
Z8 (48) 37-14, 14+
Z9 (24) 19/13 (8) 2 (41) 18-13+
a (8) 18-29, 1 (13) 5 (30) 12 (24) 45+
b (41) 34-40, 46 or 9, 34-40, 46+
c (18) 20/19 (22) 5 (27) 19 (31) 32 (34) 26 (39 d) 16+
d (40) 17 (45) 6 or 50+
Second solution
Not two thematic variants
C13.
143 (48 A B C) 118 (13) 36 (42 a) 47 (31...) 42, 234+
a (26) 3 (42) 31, 232+
B (26) 48 (3 b) 232 (26*) 118 (13...) 31, 31+
b (47) 41, 118 (13...) 31, 31+
C (27 Y) 31 (45*) 234, 344+
Y (13 or 9) 422
etc+
Second
solution
14-9/26A/13.3+ A48/23/26/9-13.3+
C14.
24 (26 A) 47 (27-31) 43 (32-37 B) 25 (36) 14 (36-41) 36 (42) 37, 9+
A (43) 34 (37) 23 (32) 47 (27 C) 18 (31 D) 36 (41) 20, 20/15 (37) 47+
B (31-37) 27 (31 E) 36 (41) 20+
C (26) 36 (20) 31 (41) 46, 25+
D (41) 22 (38) 33+
E (20) 15 (41) 32+
Not two thematic variants
Anticipation / ressemblanceJ.Builo Anth 1/539
15.26.27.32/D33.D48
C15.
46 Z (28 A B C) 35 (43) 38, 24 (37) 47 (41) 36+
A (10) 5 (44 D) 24, 50+
B (44) 37, 49+
C (43) 37, 49+
D (35) 33+
Z= 37 (43 z1)=
z1 (44) 46, 49+
C16.
3-37 Z (31 A) 47x20x37, 50+
A (41) 40, 21 (39 B) 49+
B (40) 17 (45) 50+
Z= 32(27)=
C17.
2 (31 A B) 24 (37) 12-23 Z (39) 26 (8) 3 (43) 49 (48) 26 (30) 43, 23-37+
A (18) 23 (42 A1 C) 28, 18, 47+
B (9) 24 (13) 2 (42 A1) 21, 12, 47+
A1 (31) 28, 18, 26+
C (39) 49 (44) 21, 12, 49+
Z= 26 (41) 37,
44 (8) 37 (43)=
Draw
2/31/24/39.43/
C18.
VP 27 (42 A) 38, 29+
A (393) 31 (48 B C) 2-8, 3+
B (30, 49 D) 17 (42 E, 32) 43, 174+
C (49) 40, 313+
D (48) 358, 3+
E (493) 37 (34 F) 33, 48+
F (25) 3 (39) 30, 374+
C19.
VP 21, 47 (28 A B) 41 (39) 23 (7 C D E) 1 (43) 38, 29 (37) 47+
A (40) 47-33 (29 F) 35+
B (39) 30 (44) 39+
C (44) 40, 29 (6) 7 (11) 16, 11 (45) 50+
D (43) 38+
E (6) 38 (44) 40, 49 (11) 44 (16) 49+
F (45) 50 Z (28) 6 (50) 24-33+
Z= 6 (7) 24-33
(11)=
Draw
21.47/40/.47-33/7/=
C20.
25 (27 A B) 48 (23 C D) 19 Z (26-31 E) 26 (43) 49 (48) 21 Z1 (8 F) 3 (39) 30, 48+
A (23) 48, 24 (27 G) 47 (27-31) 37+
B (22) Z2 48 Z3 Z4 39, 16 (31) 32+
C (8) 2 (23) 19 (26-31) 26 (43) Z5 12 (32 H H1) 37 (49) 40, 37-19+
D (26-31) 26 (43) 39, 2 Z6 (40) 12, 35+
E (8) 2 (26-31) 26 (43) Z7 48 (49) 40, 48-30+
F (39) 43, 19-37+
G (37) 24x31+
H (49) 40+
H1 (48) 34+
Z= 14 (8 z1) 2 (26-31) 26 (43)=
Z1= 16 (8)=
Z2= 6 (8) 48 (31) 3 (42)=
Z3= 49 (39) 16 (44)=
Z4= 44 (9) 4 (31) 17 (42)=
Z5= 17 (32) 37 (49)=
Z6= 48 (32) 25 (37)=
Z7= 2-30 (48 z2) 25 (27-31)=
z1 (9) 3 (26-31, 43) 49 (48) 21/16 (39) 43, 25+
z2 (49) 17+
Second
solution
39.25/43/.48/27/.49/27-31/.21+
C21.
15 (29 A B) 39, 49+
A (19-24) 30, 7+
B (25) 30, 9/3+
C22.
39, 34, 21, 35+
Not
two thematic variants
C23.
VP 15 (16 A) 11 (7 B) 30, 1+
A (49) 44, 30, 45+
B (2) 24, 45
(40) 39 (45) 50+
Anticipation / ressemblance
Only small part оf( 35, D3 / D2б, D41, D42
С. Blankenaar, Le Jeu de Dames 6-1897 : 33 (25) 48 (3) 41-28 (21) > С23.
N.Riso Аnt.100-5-264 [4, 22, 48 – 0 / 21 – 35: 15+]
C24.
9-18 (48-26 A) 18-23 (26-8 BB’)[if (26-3) 5-14, 4-15+;
if (25-30) 4-31+] 4-15 (8-2 C) [if (25-30) 23-19+; if (8-17) 23-12 etc.] and if (17x8),15-20, if(17x3),5-14+ 23-32 (2-16) [if (25-30) 32-19+; if (2-35) 32-16 (35-2) 15-29 (2-35), 16-2+ 32-49 (16-2) 49-16(2-35),
if (25-30),5-19+, 15-29+
A (48-30) 4-15 (30-35) [if (30-2) 18-27;
if (30-48) 18-34, 15-20+; if (2-16) 27-49+;
if (2-35) 27-16 (35-2) 15-29](2-35),2-16+
18-23 (35-2) [if (25-30) 23-14+; if (35-49) 15-38+] 23-32 like in VP.
B (26-42) [B’(26-48) 4-15 (48-31) like B] 4-15 (42-31) (if (42-26) 23-12+) 23-14 (31-4)
[if (31-36) 15-47 (25-30) 5-10 (30-34) 10-4 (34-39) 14-28+; if (31-26) 14-3 (25-30) 15-33 (26-48) 3-26+] 15-47 (4-36) 14-10 (36-4) 10-15 (4-36) [if (25-30) 47-36+] 15-4+.
C (8-35) 23-32. If (35-2) 32-16 (2-35) 15-29+, if (25-30) 32-14+, if (35-49)
32-16 (49-35) 15-29+.
Second solution
C25.
VP 15 (41 A) 36 (28) 12 (32) 9 (38) 12-3 (42 B C) 20, 47+
A (29) 41 (23) 9 (39) 5 (44 D) 20, 50+
B (30) 25 (35) 48 (40) 17 (45) 50+
C (43) 20, 48+
D (43) 20, 49+
C26.
VP 48 (9-13 A a b) 9 Z1 (13) 30 (19, 42 B) 8, 47+
B (43) 8, 48+
a (42, 47 c) 41, 18+
c (48) 31, 12+
b (44) 40, 47+
Z1= 30 (42, 14)=
A (38-43) 34, 25 (14, 14) 18 Z2 (9, 12) 15 (17) 42 (21) 26 (27) 3 (20 B C) 25 (32) 20 (37) 47+
B (32) 20 (37) 47+
C (19) 9 (32) 4 (23) 15 (37 D) 10 (29, 33) 32 (39) 49+
D (28) 42 (37, 33) 27 (39) 49+
Z2= 41 (10) 23 (20, 12)=
C27.
24 (26 A B C) 23 (31 D) 21, 32+
A (21) 26 (34) 43, 24-42+
B (31) 21+
C (39) 30, 32-14+
D (11) 25 (31 E) 42, 23-34+
E (26-17) 8, 23-14+
C28.
22 (30 A) 44 (43 B) 38, 35 (38 C) 43 Z (40) 39 (45) 50+
A (34-39) 28, 43/48+
B (39) 35 (43) 38, 24 (37) 47+
C (39) 34+
Z= 49 (39)=
C29.
6 (50 A B) 12 (31 A1 C) 12-17, 36, 22, 50+
A (49) 44, 18+
A1 (45) 6-1, 18+
B (31) 50 (37) 40+
C (40) 45 (31) 12 (37 D E) 12-17+
D (45) 6-1, 36+
E (36) 12-17,
28+
Anticipation / ressemblance
See 31
Copy Vitoshkin Respublika 25/05/2004
C30.
6 (49 A) 43 (21 B) 7, 26+
A (35) 30 (8) 7, 3+
B (16) 11, 1+
C31.
6 (49 A) 44, 18+
A (50) 12 (31 B C) 127, 36 (40) 22 (45) 50+
B (45) 6-1, 18+
C (40) 45 (31) 12 (36 D) 12-17, 28+
D (45) 6-1, 36+
Anticipation / ressemblance
See 29
Copy Vitoshkin Respublika 25.05.2004.
C32.
3 (49 A B C) 16 (47 D) 28-32, 38, 14+
A (47) 30, 33, 48+
B (42-48) 16 (49) 28-32, 43, 20+
C (30) 35 (49) 28-44, 49 (47/48) 38/43+
D (48) 28-32,
43, 20+
Draw
3/43-48/.39/30/=
C33.
2 Z1 (393 A B) 12 Z2 (48 C) 2-8, 3+
A (20) 42, 29+
B (383) 48 (49) 9, 9-13+
C (49) 40, 313+
Z1= 48 (42, 43)=
Z2= 48 (42, 48)=
Not two thematic variants
C34.
VP 14 (31 A B) 36 (42) 37, 35+
A (42) 28, 25 (38) 48+
B (34) 41/46 (40) 32, 35+
C35.
13-18 (43 A B) 40 (25 C D) 49 (48) 8-26 (17) 3, 49-21+
A (24) 30 Z, 48 (44) 30+
B (16) 40 (43) 48 (49) 8-35 Z1 (24) 2, 48-30+
C (48) 40-12, 3, 6+
D (49) 31-13, 2, 15+
Z= 40 (29 z1) 16 (44)=
Z1= 2 (35) 48-30 (24) 30 (21) 43 (26)=
z1 (30) 35 (43)
48+
Ressemblance/anticipation
S.Swart De Avondpost 1915. Anth V-14
Attiel 1979 Anth V-1
J.Viegever Het Nieuwe Damspel 1984 Anth v-16
C36.
29 (3 A B) 12, 25+
A (14) 22, 33, 3+
B (22) 18/13 (3) 20, 34/30+
Not two thematic variants
Second solution
C37.
44 Z (27-32) 22 (37 A B a) 47 z (23 C D E) 12 (36-41) 36 (42) 3 Z1 (47 F) 4 (42/24) 20, 47+
A (24) 27 (41) 23 (47) 41, 4+
B (41) 38, 39, 46+
C (36-41) 36 (42) 47 (48) 24, 39+
D (24) 15 (36-41) 31 Z2, 23 (47) 23-29+
E (42) 2 (41) 22-13 (46/47) 23/29+
F (48) 36-31, 22-17+
Z= 23 (33) 21/16 (28)=
Z1= 26 (48 y) 22-17 (43)=
Z2= 47 (46 y1) 28 (37-41 y2)=
z= 33 (17) 1 (25) 34 919) 28 (24) 28-33 (24-30) 29 (35) 18 (30) 45 (14) 23 (19) 14 (40) 28 (45) 6 (50) 12 (34) =
y (47) 4 (20/38) 42, 15+
y1 (42) 29 (47) 22-33 (36) 22+
y2 (42) 29+
a (23) 1* (41) 22-18 (37 b) 47 (46 c) 41 (42) 28/37+ *Too 12 (41) 47 (46) 41, 27+
b (46) 14+
c (42) 38/33+
C38.
38 (22-28) 49 Z Z1 (29-33 A a) 7 Z2 (39) 2 Z3 (32 B) 27 (44) 27-13, 49+
A (30) 50 (29-33 b) 45 (39) 7 Z4 (24 D) 11 Z5 (33) 32 Fin Shelomentsev 1956 (29 E F) 2 (35) 11 (34) 23 (38 G) 50 A.Saveliev 1927 (35-40 H H1) 45 (42/43) 29, 47/48+
B (33) 35 Z6 (43 C) 30, 49+
C (38) 30, 16/32 (40) 11 (45) 50+
D (32) 16/27 (44) 40, 7 (23) 25 (40) 39 (45) 50+
E (34) 2 (29 J) 11 (40) 32-28, 35 (33) 30 (38) 48+
F (35) 6 (30 E1) 23 (40) 45 (38) 50 (43 H2) 39+
G (35-40) 32-28, 35 (39) 49+
H (42) 40, 47+
H1 (43) 40, 48+
J (40) 49+
E1 (40) 32-28+
H2 (42) 34, 47+
Z= 43 (28-33) 40 z (30) 25 (38) 48 Z7 (33) 18 (39) 2/13 (42/43)=
Z1= 50 (30) 2/13 (32) 35 (37)=
Z2= 12 (39) 7 (30) 34 Z8 (43, 39)=
Z3= 11 (33) 2 (38 y) 14 (30 y1) 35 (43)=
Z4= 12 (24) 7 (33 y2) 11 (34) 6 (30) 32 (43) 48 (40) 25 (45)=
Z5= 34 (44 y3) 35, 32 (44)=
Z6= 27 (44) 27-13, 49 (39)=
Z7= 20 (33) 18 (24 y4, 24)=
Z8= 2 (32) 35 (37)=
y (44) 35 (29) 30 (38) 34+
y1 (29) 23, 7 (22)
11+
y2 (35) 11
(33) 32, Variant A.
y3 (43) 19+
y4 (39) 42/47 (43) 38, 4+
y5 (44) 40, 29+
a (28-33) 50 (28) 39, 32/46+
b (35) 17/11 (34) 8 (34-40) 30+
z= 50 (34) 6 (40)=
For instance 50 y (45) 32 (30) 38 (35) 38-33 (40) 20 (29) 33 (44, 24, 50)=
y= 38 (30) 20 (35) 50 (45) 38 (28) 6 (50) 29 (24, 45)=
Congratiulations and remarks
The FMJD is very pleased to announce that Mr. A. Fedoruk is the first World Champion End Game composition. He participated with outstanding end games and fully deserves the title. Formally there is still room for remarks, but given the fact that Mr. Céron received only a few comments after the publication of the preliminary result, it is extremely unlikely that the achievement of Mr. Fedoruk will not be confirmed.
He had to compete with a number of very experienced composers; a number of the top compositions of the three categories are among the best compositions ever produced.
In this respect the PWCE is a great success and these outstanding compositions are the by far most important result of this contest.
However, it was also the very first PWCE and that has proved to be difficult for the jury, the contact, the CPI and the FMJD. It was difficult for the participants as well, the RI /RIE have been misunderstood in a number of cases and about half of the participating end games were eliminated unanimously by the jury.
All the three jury members did their best from the start of the judgment process on, but later serious trouble about only a few end games escalated even to such an extent that an unacceptable situation resulted. The RI /RIE did not foresee a situation where some of the jury members do not have a normal cooperation with the contact of the PWCE, act as what is called in court not responsible for their action and do not follow the instructions of the FMJD that has the final responsibility for each official World Championship.
Normally the CPI should handle such differences of opinion, but the internal cooperation in the CPI was not good enough to reach common decisions.
This is why the Executive Board of the FMJD had to take the decisions required. An extensive discussion resulted in fundamental decisions regarding the CPI and such that the final result of the PWCE could be published finally.
Pieter Hildering and I are used to take decisions, but for me the combination of being a member of the Executive Board, CPI President and PWCE participant was not easy.
As CPI President I had to check if the RI /RIE and the FMJD policy as discussed before the PWCE and explained to the jury members were applied, independently of if somebody else composed the end game concerned or I. However, I tried not to influence the results more than a CPI President not participating would have done when asked for a decision.
Fortunately, the disputes concerning the elimination or not of a few end games did not have any influence on who would win the World title.
Anyway, when the jury members could not agree and the contact asked the opinion of the CPI, I did not give my opinion at once, but asked the opinion of Mr. Kaciuska and Mr. Matus first.
As said above the cooperation in the CPI was not as it should be, but nevertheless the general opinion at least for some of the end games was that they should be accepted. In particular for the best of these five end games, the situation was reached that two jury members and all three CPI members agreed that the end game should be accepted. I was set at ease to see that everybody agreed with accepting my end game, by the way it was not my best end game participating in that category.
Nevertheless Mr. P. Shkludov refused to cooperate and did not listen to the arguments of the other jury members and the CPI why the end game should be accepted.
Later he was given a last chance by Mr. Hildring, but Shkludov preferred to make insulting statements on Internet.
Also Mr. R. Mackevicius did not take the chance to give proper arguments based upon the RI /RIE and to apply normal scores for a few of the other cases, by the way all of no interest for the final result.
Finally the decision was taken to not only take the scores of Mr. G. de Bruijn, but also of the other jury members before they were fired. If they would be neglected it should have been in my personal advantage as participant, but I do not care less. It is far more important that the final result is as acceptable as possible for the participants.
We are very grateful for the efforts of Mr. G. de Bruijn and his independent judgement. We are also obliged to Mr. Céron, who kept on as contact though he found the lack of cooperation of Mr. Shkludov and Mr. Mackevicius very hard if not impossible to work with.
The FMJD also wants to thank the participants for their patience. We all learned a lot of this first PWCE.
J.C.R. Bus
CPI President
Word documents:
